Sunday, September 8, 2013

My Makie Doll, "Glythia," from the Makie Lab!

Makies are large-headed, highly articulated 10" dolls that are made in London.  These dolls are special because each one is custom made from a unique digital design created by the customer.  How does that work?  Well, there's an easy-to-use customization tool on the Makie website that allows you to play around with various facial features, skin tones, wigs and clothes until you have a doll that looks good to you.  It's a lot like designing a character on the Stardoll site--or in Skyrim, for any Dovahkiin readers out there.  Once you have perfected your character, the Makie Lab uses a 3D printer to turn your digital design into an actual doll.  It's a pretty incredible idea.

Molly first told me about Makies way back in August of last year.  After her tip, I immediately went and checked out the Makie Lab website.  This is an extremely fun site because you don't have to buy anything or have any special skills to have fun designing a Makie.  You can have as many virtual dolls as you want, change their features, write stories about them, plan outfits, and share your creations on social networks...all for free.  If you want, you can also have the character you designed made into a real doll.

I have been enjoying the Makie website immensely, and have designed and re-designed about 8 virtual dolls. However, it has taken me a whole year to actually place an order for the real thing.  It took me this long partly because I couldn't decide which of my virtual Makies to make real.  I also couldn't stop making little changes to my designs.  Another obstacle is that having a doll made and shipped to the United States costs about $180, which is a hefty sum to spend on one doll.

As in so many situations, curiosity eventually trumped reason, and I bought a doll.  I was simply too eager to see how my creation would translate into three dimensions, and too curious about how a 3D printed doll would look and feel.  Now that my doll has arrived, I am excited to share the whole experience with you.

Custom Makie, "Glythia," by The Makie Lab.
Let me start by showing you some features of the design tool.  Honestly, you'll have more fun if you just go to the website and try it for yourself, but here's a quick tour so that you know what to expect.  The design features have changed a bit since I first started making Makies last year.  The very first Makies were all pale white, but now there are four different skin tone choices, so you start the fun by choosing a gender and a skin tone.  Here's the first screen with a green girl selected:
You can also choose a name and create a backstory.
If you click on a skin tone button, your doll will change on the screen.  You can choose between Ice Frosting (white), Strawberry Milk (pink), Pale Pistachio (green) and Cocoa Bean (brown):


I'll switch to a Makie boy so that you can see what the basic boy characters look like.  They have more angular faces:


You can zoom in on the face to make changes to different facial features.  For example, there are six different eye colors to choose from, three basic eye shapes, three eyebrows, and then seven sliding buttons to fine-tune the eye area proportions.  There are screens like this for the nose, mouth and ears, too.


You can rotate the image whenever you want to check out how your head looks from different angles:


There are a lot of fun options here, and you can easily spend an entire afternoon (or an entire year...) testing out all of the combinations.  You can make a grumpy green guy:


Or a more normal-looking happy guy:


I love the elf ear feature, so most of my characters have the biggest elf ears that are possible.  

Once you settle on a face, you can pick from a bunch of different hairstyles and outfits.  Here's my character, Giddeon, with his huge elf ears and his tousled black hair:


Here's Giddeon in the outfit I would be most likely to purchase for him:


Many of the outfits are strange.  It's a good idea to go to the Makie shop and look at photographs of the actual outfits if you're thinking of purchasing a doll.  Here are some examples of the digital outfit and its real counterpart:


That's a fill error with Giddeon's eyes in the picture above--you can't actually choose all-black alien eyes (unfortunately).



Now I'll switch over and show you some pictures of the digital Makie I decided to make real.  She's actually the first character I ever made--an elf, named Glythia after my Dungeons and Dragons character.  And yes...I'm that geeky.

Notice that I designed her on August 17th, 2012. 

The fairy outfit isn't for sale, or I would have bought that.
I changed her outfit and tweaked her face and fussed over her hair for a whole year.  Her final incarnation has Strawberry Milk skin and is wearing a limited edition orange dress, matching orange shoes, and a black cape.  


She has a little bit of a smile and very wide green eyes.  I chose the short red "Tiger" wig for her.


Custom Makies cost 99 pounds (~150 dollars).  There seem to be a number of different deals in terms of what extras you get with that price.  Glythia came with everything I had her wearing in her picture (dress, cape, wig and shoes), but I think that is because she's an older design and you got more for your money a year ago.  If I design a Makie today, and want her to be wearing everything Glythia has, I can give her a dress and a wig in the design stage (the orange dress isn't available here anymore), but there's no option for shoes or extra outfit items like the cape:

This doll would cost $150 as is.
So, I have to add the cape and the shoes separately, which is another $36.  


If I understand this correctly, to get a Makie, a wig, a dress, a cape and a pair of shoes would cost about $190 alone, so over $200 with international shipping.  I seem to have gotten a really good deal on my doll. 

A few weeks after I placed my order, I visited the site and saw that this picture had been stealthily added to my gallery!

Finally made real!


I knew from lurking around the Makie Me website for the last year that Glythia was not going to look exactly like her digital self.  None of the Makies look exactly like their pictures.  However, after gazing at my cartoon Glythia for so long, it was a bit of a shock to see her as a real doll.  I wasn't instantly thrilled with how she came out.  Specifically, I found myself wishing I'd given her a bigger smile.  Despite that slight regret, I was thrilled that she was finally on her way to the United States!

After a few chipper, entertaining emails from Makie Me, updating me on Glythia's progress, she arrived on my doorstep.  She came in a sturdy plastic bubble envelope with these two packages inside:

A black cardboard poster tube and a black envelope.
Both the tube and the envelope have colorful Makie stickers on them:



The cardboard tube has a white plastic lid on each end.  These lids can easily be removed to peek inside:


I can see Glythia's huge elf ears in there!  That's exciting!  I was surprised to see that there's no bubble wrap or any other kind of protective packing, though.  It's kind-of amazing that the ears aren't broken.


There were a few rolls of paper in the tube with my doll.  The first is a certificate of authenticity:


It's weird because the "made real" date on the certificate doesn't match the date on the website:

August 12th.
August 15th.
The second roll of paper was a poster with a lot of great information about the doll:


This "Crash Course in Makies Maintenance, Care and Love" describes how the Makie body does and doesn't come apart, how to clean it (it's dishwasher safe!), and how to swap eyes and make other modifications.  It looks like all of the joints come apart except for the knees and elbows.  

Because I was surprised by the lack of bubble wrap in my Makie's packaging, this part of the poster was consoling:


It explains that while Makies feel like porcelain, they are made out of plastic, so they're tougher than they look.  Tough as boots, apparently.

Next, I slid out Glythia herself.  She came tied to a black cardboard support:


That first glimpse of her face was a little freaky...

ALIEN INVASION!  RUN!!
Glythia's wig and a small package of shoes came out with her:


The shoe box is made out of black corrugated cardboard and has a sticker that says, "here are some shoes."  It's so polite!

Thank you for the shoes! 
Here's Glythia on her cardboard stretcher.  She's tied on there with a golden ribbon and is wearing her limited edition orange dress (no cape):


I'm surprised that she's right up against black cardboard--there doesn't seem to be any concern about color transfer--or maybe it doesn't matter since you can just pop her in the dishwasher? 

Here she is standing on her own two feet:


My first impression was that she is very lightweight.  She doesn't feel cheap, but she doesn't feel like porcelain to me at all.  I think she has the soft, light, almost fuzzy feel of balsa wood.  

In terms of her appearance, my first reactions were that her head is much larger than it looked online, and her body is much shorter and stockier.  Also, her eyes are huge and really beautiful.  

She is a very, very strange-looking doll:


Her limited edition orange dress is actually quite simple, and clearly handmade, with a beautiful woven fabric that reminds me of ginkgo leaves:


The dress is a basic sheath with two tucks in the front of the bodice and a velcro closure with a single metal snap at the top.


There are a few little sewing mistakes, which is frustrating for a $17 dress:


Glythia has 13 points of articulation.  All of her joints are ball-and-socket:


She has a short, athletic torso that seems oddly realistic given her enormous head and exaggerated facial features.  She doesn't have the super-skinny body that other large-headed dolls like La Dee Da, Cutie Pops and Pullip have.


She has an area on her back that looks like a battery compartment:


The Makie poster explains that this compartment is, in fact, designed to hold batteries so that you can insert electronic mods into the doll's head:

Awesome!
This excerpt mentions a "Lilypad Arduino," which I had never heard of before.  It's a small programmable computer that can sense environmental inputs and react with lights or sound.  It's meant for making interactive clothing, but I suppose that the size makes it great for use in dolls, too.


The neck is hollow to accommodate wires coming down from the head:

Ultimate nerd doll.
Here's the lower part of the battery compartment:


The battery compartment cover has Glythia's unique identification code:


The body color is not uniform.  Glythia's torso, for example, is very pale, while her limbs have more of the Strawberry Milk color in them.  This ends up looking pretty good, I think.  It looks like a natural tanning pattern or artistic shading:


3D printers work by applying lots of very thin layers of plastic on top of each other.  If you look closely at some areas of Glythia's body, you can see these tiny layers.  I think these lines are what make me think of wood grain when I hold this doll:


Glythia's head must be sanded, because the printing lines are not visible on her face:


Glythia is so pale, it is tricky to see the texture of her face in photographs.  Her head is smoother than her limbs, but it still has some roughness:


Glythia's green eyes are amazing.  I am tempted to purchase more of these eyes just to see if the other colors are as interesting.


Up close, the detail in her eyes reminds me of chloroplasts (the organelle in a plant that is responsible for photosynthesis):


Real chloroplasts (through a microscope).
Here's a closer look at one of Glythia's cool elf ears:


The Makie poster describes how the top of the doll's head can be removed and the eyes can be swapped.  It seems very simple:


Sure enough, the head pops right off (I'll admit that I got a little nervous that the thin plastic would break...but it didn't):




The eye mechanism reminds me of my MiM doll.  The eyes are attached to a clip that snaps in and out.  It looks very simple to use.  Glythia's unique identifier is carved into the eye mechanism, too:


Glythia's head has a great range of motion, thanks to her ball-jointed neck:



This doll poses like a dream.  She is very well-balanced and can strike a huge range of poses.  She can stand on her own for ages and not fall down.  She's rock solid.  

She seems very pale and bare with no wig and no clothes, but it's the best way to see her joints in action:


I'll show you a bunch of pictures of what she can do.  She has a few irritating limitations which I'll point out as I go, but for the most part I am absolutely thrilled with her articulation.


She can kneel, but her knee joints don't bend past 90 degrees, so she needs a bit of weight tipped back over her feet to prevent her from falling forwards.


In fact, all of her limb joints bend to about 90 degrees and then stop.  This is good enough for most poses, but I occasionally wish she could bend her elbows and knees a bit more.


If her legs are moved straight out to the sides, she can only get about this far with a side-to-side split:


With her hip joints rotated upwards, she can do a full split:


She can't quite do a front-to-back split with her hips all of the way flat on the ground, but she gets pretty close.  


Here you can see how her hips and knees make nice right angles:


She sits well in a chair and has some rotation in her legs so that she can keep her knees together.  The leg rotation does not come from the knee joint as it does in Monster High dolls, but rather from rotation at the hip.  The knees and elbows do not rotate at all--they act more like hinge joints.  The shoulders, wrists, ankles, hips and neck have full rotational movement.



She is balanced so well that she can stand on one foot.  In this pictures she is leaning up against a wall...


But here she's flying solo:


She sits nicely on a flat surface, and also at the edge of a table. She would be a fun little desk companion at work, I think, as long as you weren't worried about scaring away your colleagues.


Here's a closer look at some of her ball joints:




If you look at her hand up close, you can see those printer layers again:



Here's Glythia's body disassembled--everything comes apart really easily, except for the elbow and knees joints:



This is the ball of the neck joint (hollow to accommodate wires):



These are the arms:



The upper arms and upper legs have hollow cylindrical centers that are filled with white rubber plugs.  I am not sure what purpose they serve:


Here are the legs:


Here's the knee joint up close.  It is a ball and socket joint, but it does not have any rotational movement:


I have some slight concerns about how all of these joints might loosen over time.  A leg fell off once when I was posing Glythia, but other than that the connections seem tight.  

Here's Glythia all put back together again:

Whoa.  I think I just had an out-of-body experience.
Glythia informed me about halfway through the review that she has a black smudge on her foot:

You see it there, Emily?  Can you fix that?

I figured that this would be a good time to test the washable nature of Makies.  I wasn't quite brave enough to put Glyth in the dishwasher, but I did scrub her foot with Dawn dish soap and an abrasive scrubbing sponge. 


It took a bit of effort (more scrubbing than I expected) but the spot did come off:


The "Tiger" synthetic wig that came with Glythia is of decent quality.  It's not super-soft, but it is thick and has a nice cloth wig cap and a pretty red color.


It doesn't have an obvious style when you first get it on...


But it can be tamed into something that looks reasonable.  It's hard to control all of the stray hairs with this style though.


Glythia can tuck this hair behind her large ears to help keep it under control:


Here she is back in her orange dress with her wig on.


The shoes that I chose for Glythia are 3D printed orange pumps.  These come with a whole new pair of feet:


I pulled off the old feet to get ready for the new ones.  



Here's the exposed ball side of the foot joint:


At first, the two styles of foot didn't look that different to me:


On closer inspection, though, I realized that the extra foot has a more defined arch:


Here's Glythia's original flat foot inside of the shoe:


And the extra foot that came with the shoe:


The thin strap of this shoe is made out of the same hard plastic as the doll.  It seems like it could be really fragile, and at first I was nervous to bend it around too much.  Because that strap is so thin, though, it has a fair amount of bend to it, making it more resilient than I expected.



Glythia stands very well in her shoes, too:


The cape that I ordered for Glythia came inside of a wax paper envelope with another Makie sticker.  This is what was inside of that black envelope I showed at the beginning.


The cape is black velour.  It photographs strangely, but it's actually pitch black with a true red collar:


The cape is nicely made.  The cape and the collar are both double-layered and carefully sewn.


Here's a comparison of my digital Glythia, and the real Glythia--fully dressed:



The likeness is better than I originally thought.  It's definitely the doll I designed.

The cape was a great addition in the digital world, but I don't think I'll use it much on the actual doll.  The deep black color makes Glythia look way too pale.

Glythia's clothes restrict her awesome posing, but here she is doing her best to model her orange dress and shoes:






So, at this point I was starting to get used to the way Glythia looks.  Especially with her wig in place, she doesn't look quite as much like an alien as I originally thought:

An alien, Emily?  Really?  That's harsh.
But...then I took off her wig and introduced her to some of the doll gang, and she started to look a little funny again in comparison:

Monster High, Bratzillaz, Makie, Liv, Ever After High.
She's significantly shorter than most of my play dolls, and her torso is much thicker.  She comes closest to a Liv doll's body proportions, and some of the Liv clothes fit pretty well.  Here's Glythia in Hayden's dress from the Hayden's House set:


The dress has a nice loose cut and allows Glythia to move around a lot:


Some of the other Liv styles, like this tight-fitting Liv Brites dress, don't work as well.  


It doesn't quite close in the back:


Glythia's torso size is more similar to some of my larger play dolls, like Moxie Teenz and City Girls:


The pants on these larger dolls are way too long for Glythia, but the tops make cute little dresses.  In this next picture, she's wearing a City Girl top and, just for fun, I tried a MiM wig on her.  The wig is a little big, but could be held on with some moleskin or a few rubber bands:


Here's Glythia in my other MiM wig--I like this one even better:


Here she is in a Moxie Teenz shirt:


Glythia's head circumference is 7 inches, so she'd probably wear size 7 wigs.  My MSD size 8-9 wigs are too big.

Here's Glythia with some dolls that I think of as being 10 inches tall:

Pinkie Cooper (Pepper), Makie, Cutie Pops Candi.
In reality, Pinkie Cooper is actually more like 8.5 inches tall, and while Glythia is advertised as being 10 inches tall, she's more like 9.5 inches.  Cutie Pops are 10.5 inches tall.

Oh, thank goodness.  You're even stranger than I am.
The best clothing fit I found is actually not from a doll I even thought about putting in the lineups with Glythia.  Only Hearts Club clothes fit pretty well.  This Only Hearts Club sweatsuit fits, and allows Glythia to practice some of her moves:




Glythia's removable hands were very convenient for trying on all of these different clothes.  She wouldn't have been able to fit her large hands into some outfits, like this Disney Store Cinderella dress, if her hands had been permanently attached:



Another thing I was aware of as I tried on clothes was that while this doll's limbs feel smooth to the touch in most areas, they do have some rough patches that can snag on clothes and make dressing a little frustrating.

I settled on dressing Glythia in Liv doll shorts and a green Only Hearts Club top.  The shirt is short, but it has a cute crop-top look, and I enjoy all of the green.  I think Glythia might be related to my mossy friend, Oscar.  Outside in the woods, Glythia's pale face is much easier to photograph...and her eyes are vibrant:




The Makie poster mentions that Makies can be painted with makeup or acrylic paint.  


I decided to put a little color on Glythia's wide mouth. I used acrylic paints, diluted with a lot of water so that I didn't get an overdone look with one brush stroke.  Here's Glythia with her lips painted:


I was hoping that the extra color would make her photograph better but she still looks very washed-out in her pictures:


I took her outside to her mossy tree stump to try and capture the real color of her new face paint.  Maybe I'll try some blush next?





Bottom line?  Wow.  This is an unusual, spectacular doll.  I have never had a doll buying experience quite like this, nor have I ever seen a doll that looks, feels and moves quite like a Makie.  Of all the dolls I have owned, I suppose Glythia is most similar to a Fairyland Little Fee resin BJD.  However, Glythia is not strung, so she poses better than many resin dolls, and she's very lightweight in comparison.  She's also more user-friendly than most resin BJDs.  You don't have to know how to string elastic, you don't have to keep her out of sunlight, you don't have to use putty to keep her eyes in place, and you don't have to worry about breakage or dirt.  She goes in the dishwasher, for goodness sake!  Glythia is missing the ethereal, heart-melting beauty or cuteness that many Asian BJD faces offer.  Her face takes some getting used to, but I think her incredible repertoire of poses gives her more than enough personality to make up for her unusual face. 

These little dolls are excellent character companions.  They are portable, posable and durable, and would be really cute on display at a desk or lurking in various locations throughout the house.  For that purpose, an exaggerated face might be more fun, but Glythia manages to get plenty of giggles and groans for her straight-faced antics...doing yoga on the piano, popping up next to the breakfast cereal, contemplating a formidable pile of homework, or inviting herself along for a car ride:





The process of designing Glythia was great.  Even after a year, I still enjoy stopping by the Makie website and creating a new character.  I would love to be able to order another real doll some day.  I wish I could pay less and order a doll with no clothes, though.  I think this was an option a few months ago, but it doesn't seem to be anymore.  The clothes don't add much to the doll and in fact, the orange dress I chose seriously restricts Glythia's movement--which is one of her best features.  Plenty of other (less expensive) doll clothes work just fine, and sewing unique outfits for a Makie would probably be very rewarding.

Glyth with another Only Hearts Club top and the same Liv shorts.
I like Glythia more and more each day, but I think it's still too soon for me to pass a final judgement on her.  The most exciting thing about Makies is how customizable they are--even after they've gone to print.  I have only just gotten started exploring these options.  A full face-up would transform Glythia's pale, slightly blank face into something much more dynamic.  A funky, colorful wig would add a lot to her personality, too.  I am even tempted by the idea of making her interactive with a programmable computer chip...then she could be lurking near the breakfast cereal and actually say something when one of my teenagers showed up to eat.


The creativity and ingenuity in this company is amazing.  The dolls offer a wonderful way for people to express themselves.  When I browse the photographs of completed Makies on the website, I am fascinated by how customers have conveyed their own individual styles so effectively with the simple tools and accessories that are available.  I am starting to realize that, while I had some initial regrets about Glythia's mild expression, the face I designed reflects one side of my personality in an unexpectedly accurate way.  Glythia's calm, slightly worried appearance mirrors the side of me that is cautious and overly analytical.  There's a scatterbrained, goofy side to me too, though, and I will do my best to capture that with my next Makie.

I really want the small London-based MakieWorld company to succeed, and I am happy to see that they have grown and expanded over the past year.  One barrier that concerns me is that the dolls are too expensive to be purchased on a whim right now.  The price is understandable--Makies are not mass-produced, and they're all one-of-a-kind and beautifully articulated.  However, if they were closer to the $60-$80 range, more people would cave to the temptation of seeing their own personal design come to life.  

As for me, I am so glad that I finally caved to this particular temptation...even with the hefty price tag.  Glythia has been such a fun project so far, and she is by no means complete.  More than that, though, when I look at Glythia, I feel like I am looking into the future.  This kind of custom-printed doll could quickly become the norm, and Makie did it first.  I feel ecstatic to have this ground-breaking, charismatic creature in my collection.



60 comments:

  1. What a cool concept! Glythia looks great, and I love that these dolls can be painted. Thanks for introducing me to this amazing company!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, N! I hope you have fun on the site! :)

      Delete
  2. I'm so glad to see you do a review on the Makie doll. I've been following your reviews for some time and have thought of suggesting it. I've only had my Makie (Willa) for 3 months or so (though I have the original joints as opposed to the joints Glythia has). The realistic body shape and great articulation quickly made her my favorite. Thank you for mentioning that the Only Hearts clothes fit, I hadn't thought to try them. Lalaloopsy tops also fit with a crop top style though the bottoms are far too big. Stretchy Blythe clothing fits well too.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh--I remember Willa from the Makie site!! She has a wonderful huge grin! That's so cool. I remember her in particular because of her name (which I love) and because of her happy face. :D

      Thank you for the clothing tips. I almost tried my Blythe dress on Glythia, but figured it'd be too small. I will try it now!

      Does your Willa have the hinged knees? I noticed that some of the dolls had different knees. I'd love to know what the other differences are! Hinged knees are actually quite realistic, since that's the kind of knee joint humans have!

      I am so glad to hear that you love your Willa. She's great!

      Delete
    2. Thank you. I love her grin too, it is so much warmer than I expected!! Of course, she desperately needs some color in her face so it won't be washed out in pictures (as you noted can happen). I think that will make the smile even better :)

      Beware that the Blythe clothing must be stretchy to work well. Some of the narrow arm holes are impossible to get into and, of course, the Blythe waist and hips are much smaller than the Makie doll's.

      Willa has the original version of the elbows and knees instead of the brand new stream lined ones Glythia has. They changed them just recently and I am debating buying a new body for her. You can see some shots of Willa's joints on my Flickr here:
      http://www.flickr.com/photos/21844291@N07/8998553648/
      http://www.flickr.com/photos/21844291@N07/8998565362/

      And this one doesn't show her joints as well but does show functionality:
      http://www.flickr.com/photos/21844291@N07/8999896705/
      I was a little nervous but her crossed ankles are all that is holding her upside down on that tree limb!

      Delete
  3. She is awesome! I so want to get one of these (I've been making them online for a while too...), soon I hope!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for introducing these dolls to me, Molly! That website has been one of my regular stops over the last year. I hope you get a real Makie soon, too!

      Delete
  4. Wow--this is fascinating! Makies are pretty much fairly low cost BJD (relative to the cost of BJD which spike up to 400-500 in some spots) and a lot more durable in tons of ways--I always get afraid I'll drop Nikki when I'm posing her or carrying her anywhere, which is why I'm more inclined to pose with Marie. I'm going to bookmark that site and keep my eyes/funds open for a time to buy one. Already I'm thinking of how one would look with a neat little face up and added lashes, and designed clothing. The ability to pick everything from eye color to eye tilt and nose width means I could easily make a lovely black doll--and they might even be dyeable.

    Nine to ten Makies have probably already been banned from DoA; they're hyper elitist about anything not made of lung-searing resin. When I got my Obitsu, I got lectured that she wasn't actually a BJD because she wasn't strung resin even though she's highly customized (down to her body scars). Soured me to the whole place, which is why I wandered away.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Nethilia,

      Though you can choose a dark skin now, originally you could only get ice white and people did a lot of experimenting with dying. Check the Makie forums to learn more about the experiments other owners have done (they've used tea as well as dyes). Though this blog entry probably covers enough for making a black doll: http://makiecouture.blogspot.co.uk/2013/03/more-science.html
      My Delicious Bliss has made a beautiful black Makie which you can see on Flickr:
      http://www.flickr.com/photos/mydeliciousbliss/8687132449/in/pool-2084145@N24/

      Delete
    2. Ooo, thank you! I will keep those in my bookmarks!

      Delete
    3. I'm sorry about your experience with DoA! Honestly, you're not the only one that feels that way and most people seem to use the site as a source of information rather than any kind of "community" :/ (it's up for debate whether the mods are just trying to keep things under control or over control, but I'm new so I'm not sure). There are more BJD forums out there that accept Obitsus (which are awesome) and BJD type dolls that aren't resin/strung/both. There are also a lot that are a LOT more friendly.

      On the subject of Makies, they probably ARE banned because they're not strung and made of resin. The only non-resin dolls they allow are vinyl dollfies :/ Boo :(

      Delete
    4. Uck, yeah, 'elitist' is exactly how I would describe den of angels. I've heard so many stories of people being scared away from the place because the people there can be really, really rude. Also, I'm pretty sure you can't sign up there unless someone who already has an account invites you. :/ That's definitely an effective way to keep people out...

      Delete
  5. Oh my gosh, what a cool concept! I've never heard of these before but I'm smitten already. I love the creative aspect to it and all of the customization options available. Endless possibilities! And I adore Glythia's green chloroplast eyes. Anyways, I'm off to go play around with this website even though I should be working on my first review for my blog!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Have fun on the site, Heather! It's a blast. And let us know how your review goes!!

      Delete
  6. Ah they look so nice! I might have to get one! Or at least play around with the maker :3

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Birdie! That making tool is addictive, and it's a great way to stay occupied and have some Makie fun if you're not quite ready to buy the actual doll! :)

      Delete
  7. Fascinating doll. She makes me think of a house elf from Harry Potter. LOL! Now I want to investigate their web site.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I thought she reminded me of something! At first I thought that it might have been the abundance of red-heads in Emily's collection, but now I know what it was: Dobby! She could be his sister or something, IDK!
      Juliet

      Delete
    2. It is so neat that you posted this! My son and I have been calling Glythia the "house elf," for the last few days, and I almost put that in the post! :P She'd fit right into the Harry Potter world!

      Delete
  8. I know I'm repeating myself, but I just love reading your reviews. I hadn't even HEARD of this company before and when you mentioned the price tag I almost dropped off completely--but by the end you had me in total lust with this crazy new line! If they ever drop to under $100 with shipping, I might just have to prize open the wallet. Also, one of my favorite things about your reviews is you're all "doll stuff doll stuff doll stuff and oh here have some science for fun". I LOVE snippets of new information in unexpected places. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you so much, Tina! Your comments always brighten my day. :)

      My husband actually had a similar reaction to Glythia--he said, "If those ever go down to $60, I want one, too!" He's eager to add the computer chip mods, I think. Perhaps if the dolls become more popular, MakieWorld will be able to lower the price? I don't know--we can hope!

      Delete
    2. I was playing around on the site and I figured out how to order a nude Makie--just don't pick an outfit (or if you have, just click the pieces again to remove them). That cut about $30 off the price...which is STILL too high for me, but at least that's been figured out. :)

      Delete
  9. well the doll of the future, I'm glad to finally see a doll made using a 3D printer it's really cool. I imagine lots of youtubers who make videos with their dolls as the characters wanting to do the computer thing with this doll so all they have to do is have the doll say it's line and do the movements, no hands required. ;)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh--you're right! YouTube videos of this doll would be incredible! I need a better stop action set-up and then even I might give that a try! Great idea. :)

      Delete
  10. As soon as she has eyelashes and eyebrows, she'll come to life!
    Thankyou for this fabulous review!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you Saffy! I tried drawing her eyebrows in with watercolor pencil, but it didn't quite stick well enough. I think you're absolutely right, though--a little more color around her eyes and she'll be even better! :D

      Delete
  11. The molded on eyebrows are an interesting idea- I'm thinking they chose to make them raised so that completely unpainted dolls look nicer (since no eyebrows automatically raises all sorts of red flags for the human brain somehow..) but it does limit you a bit, for instance it'd be hard or impossible to stencil the eyebrows on. Which is basically the easiest way to do them.
    I would like more varied eye shapes to be an option, but with how fast MakieWorld seems to be expanding it's not unlikely that more in-depth customization will show up eventually. Thank you for the awesome review as always :D

    ReplyDelete
  12. I am by no means a doll collector (although I still have my old Barbies and My Little Pony) I love your reviews and you're definitely making me want one of these :D

    I imagine in the future the price should come down as they get better known. At the moment I'd guess they're having to cover the very high cost of 3D printers and also the cost of the material used. All in all though I would say they're very good value, especially compared to BJD.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Sorry if I can't advertise on here (I'm not sure) but my emerald doll collection doll is on eBay!

    ReplyDelete
  14. Feel free to view here: http://www.ebay.com/itm/261283047518?ssPageName=STRK:MESELX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1555.l2649

    ReplyDelete
  15. Hi Emily,

    Thanks for sharing this really unique doll. The whole Makie concept is a fabulous use of 3D printing technology! I love how incredibly customizable she is. I would immediately want to get out my pastels and Prismacolors and give her a faceup, while my brother would probably wire her with robot sensors and set up doll-related pranks. I've always thought that dolls have a lot to do with self expression, and this one takes that to a whole new level.

    If you end up doing any more modifications on Glythia, I would love for you to post updates. I'm sure we'd all be interested to see how you continue to make your Makie your own.

    Also, reading through the comments, I was happy to see that I wasn't the only one who looked at Glythia and thought "house elf."

    ReplyDelete
  16. How amazing is this idea?! Thanks to your review, I have been on their website all afternoon, making dollies...not ordering yet...yet. :)

    ReplyDelete
  17. Oh my goodness that is awesome! Hum... our school has a 3D printer...do you think we could make one of these?

    ReplyDelete
  18. I don't like really much her face, but the concept overall is awesome. I'll visit the site anyways, to see and try by myself to design a doll like this. This could have been something really good if the Stardoll site had this option. I think this is great, and probably, how's going to be the doll market in the future =)

    ReplyDelete
  19. I found someone who was doing BJD cats using a 3D printer. They are kinda expensive, especially the bigger ones, tho I think it is because the material 3D printers use is expensive.

    pets.evethecat.com

    ReplyDelete
  20. I think this is an interesting idea, but the price seems high. Unless I handled an actual doll, I'm not sure I'd be willing to purchase one. The things I have handled that were made from 3D printers have always had a strange texture that I found unappealing. I just don't know how a doll make of these layers of plastic would really feel. I also find the lack of color in her face rather disquieting.

    By the way, once you mentioned D&D, the thought that "wow... it looks kinda like a gnome" just kept popping into my head.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Your Glythia is adorable, so sweet. You inspired me to google for more photos of Makies with faceups, this girl is so cute too:

    http://www.flickr.com/photos/65439432@N03/7845820546/lightbox/

    Here's a flickr group for them (not all have faceups)
    http://www.flickr.com/groups/2084145@N24/ --- so many options!

    You're right, 3D printing is going to be a HUGE business in the future, everything from household items, art/sculpture, toys, spare parts for repairs, etc. It's starting to take off now, I've seen people offer little doodads for sale they print at school/work (ahem) or at home.

    The price on home 3D printers is coming down, they will be a lot more affordable in the future though. My local library has one now and the branch manager says our craft group can use it. We need to see what our options are for free design files posted online. People selling (really cool) objects made with these things politely decline requests for the design file because they're trying to sell the printed product, and I don't blame them. It seems like designing a 3d doll would take a long time and I'll be very surprised if something that intricate is posted online at no charge for people to use on their own printer.

    It will be cool if Mattel someday posts a free file to print a replacement Monster High hand, but will they post the file for an entire doll? Maybe for sale! :) Fans will likely do it first, design their own MH doll or spare parts to print.

    ReplyDelete
  22. WOW! these dolls and the concept behind them are really something different!!! I'll give it a try, even if I'm not too sure I'll be buyin' the doll -a new nude momoko is comin' home and my wallet is still mad at me-, they're not so cheap even if to have it send to Italy I would not pay duties... but maybe for Christmas...

    ReplyDelete
  23. She's so cute! I was browsing that site not long ago and your review came right on time. :) Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  24. Thanks for showing us the process...our work filters deem the Makie site as games and so no access. Now to dig out that tiny Blackberry screen and get designing.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Thank you verry much for this review, I have been curious about the Makie dolls for a while now but I could not find a detailed review. I love how these dolls are made with 3D printers, and I would love to make dolls for myselvf with a 3D printer some day (liv doll jake needs more male friends) The faces are cute butlook a little weird to me, I think coloring the lips and eyebrows eill help alot on that. To me the wigs looks a little low quality and they dont seem to have any clothes I REALLY like. I wouldent like buying a exspencive doll + exspencive clothes and then not useing the clothes. I hope to see this doll line grow with new skin colors, new wigs, more clothes, shoes and accecories. Maybe even and option to chose lip and eyebrow color + makeup.
    Have you seen the limited edition Makies with faceups and cool clothes?

    ReplyDelete
  26. Interesting use of a 3d printer. These are sort of spooky without their paint and there's something about the head that makes it look like I'm viewing it through a wide angle lens, but they are still appealing. I think the dolls with rounder faces and smaller mouths are kind of cute. One thing that bothers me is that pictures I've seen of the brown-skinned ones have this weird texture.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Cool! I have seen these dolls around but had no idea about how they were designed and made. So interesting!! Thanks for the review. Informative as ever. xx

    ReplyDelete
  28. Okay, I didn't get to read all the way through your review...because I had to go over and make my own Makie. Just the virtual kind, but still she is really cute! I named her Xyra. She has pink hair and grey eyes...maybe someday I'll really make her.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Very cool design wise, i like that you can actually design how the doll will look. the only thing that i find fault with these dolls is that all the skin colors don't seem to match. Maybe also that they look ruff a little bit, I think i would have her sanded by someone if i was to get one. Also would think about getting her a face paint or atleast getting her eyebrows painted LOL.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Wonderful review, it took me ages to read it so I can only imagine how long it took you to write it. When I saw them I'd already read about their similarity to porcelain but like you I disagreed. I felt that they were not smooth, heavy or cold enough to resemble porcelain; to me they were more like stiffened fabric. When I saw them only their faces were unclothed so I didn't get to see the rings like trees have that you showed us in the photo on Glythia's body. I am tempted by an original boxed limited edition Ada doll. She was eyeing me from the shelf and that's that doll I asked to have a hold of in Selfridges. I let her go back into the display casing at the end of my play though as at £200 she's quite a hefty exchange of cash for little doll. On 24th October the Makies will move to the ground floor of Selfridges on Oxford Street (from the Toy Department upstairs) and they'll bring in printing machines, it's then that I plan to buy my Makie. I'll take pics of the display and post them on my blog: http://mydollbestfriend.blogspot.co.uk/2013/08/the-worlds-first-printed-3d-dolls-makies.html Love your reviews. I buy dolls after I've read them though, that's the trouble!

    ReplyDelete
  31. Oh the final picture with green looks so cute and i adore the elf ears. The best though was the cinderella dress. I absolutely love how she looked in that. Bet she'd look cute in the indian dress from the hearts dolls. Love how poses look, i might have to go play with their designs.

    ReplyDelete
  32. What a cool idea-thank you for sharing! I've seen 3-D printers in action, but would have never thought to use them for dolls. I'm also off to play around with the site, just for fun! That customizable aspect is what has made me spent hours on things like the Sims.

    ReplyDelete
  33. I LOVE the Makie doll idea! Now THAT is how to use a 3D printer. :)
    That said, I think I'll hold out and see if they'll release more body and head size options. While I like big-headed dolls (Ellowynes, LIVs), there is a certain point to me where it gets too big, and the Makies are borderline-- though, of course, that's just my personal preference. :) I've played around with the design lab and did make a face that I really liked though, so I'll see.... ;)

    Since you mentioned BJDs, I'd like to ask: Would you do a post dedicated to your BJDs? I don't have the money to actually spend on a BJD right now, but I've been researching them and drooling over the dolls from various companies, and I'd love to see pictures of yours and read your thoughts on them. :)

    Thank you for another great review and the introduction to a really clever doll company! I'll definitely be watching what Makie is up to from now on.

    --Kate :)

    ReplyDelete
  34. I have finally completed reading all your old posts and finally got to my favorite one!

    Wow! Makies! I have been playing on their website for a week now. My kids and I have made 5 makes and would love to have them all printed out. Their faces are amazing! I would have to find someone to do a face up for me if I got one.

    I am very interested in the 3D printers and this is an amazing use of them!

    Well, back to YouTube to look at more Makie blogs.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Great review. As for the price, comparing to many collectible Blythe or resin BJD they are fairly reasonable actually.

    ReplyDelete
  36. This was an amazing review. They seem to offer less choices now as far as clothing. I'm holding off until things advance. I do not like the big head but the rest of the doll looks like fun!

    ReplyDelete
  37. I had never heard of Makies until your awesome review! What a cool concept. I'd heard of 3D printing, but have never touched anything from one. As a doll lover (primarily American Girl and BJDs), the prospect of completely designing my own doll was extremely appealing, and needless to say... My first Makie should be arriving in a month or so :D

    How are you liking Glythia now that you've had her for a while?

    ReplyDelete
  38. Makies have come up on some other doll blogs/forums lately, so I've been looking at them again. Did you know that a quote from this review is front and center on their home page?

    ReplyDelete
  39. Hi, I shared a link to your excellent review on Russian forum for doll collectors: http://forum.dollplanet.ru/viewtopic.php?f=26&t=34295&p=3138305#p3138305
    Hope you don't mind.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Wow she's so interesting and and magical 0-0....you should try painting her eye brows or air brushing her with really light skin colour.

    ReplyDelete
  41. One of my Sasha-collecting friends has a 3D model of her husband...he gave it to her for her birthday. (It's not lifesize though.)

    Well, I read your review and then I went to the site and now I've ordered one. Wheeeee! - Jocelyn

    ReplyDelete
  42. Makies are going to have inclusive accessories soon (hearing aids, canes, glasses, wheelchairs, even individualized port wine stains). They're also now significantly cheaper than when you got yours, including free shipping to the states. I'd love one of these dolls, but I hate their giant heads. That said, the newer ones, especially the dark-skinned doll featured on the website, have adorable noses and lips. I'd love to hear your take on the newer ones, since you're a stickler for articulation, but still fall for a n expressive face. Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  43. I purchased mine Dec 2014 & since then Makie came out with a green skin color which I had no idea was available-& is now discontinued. I wish they had a way to notify former customers of upcoming changes. Guess it pays to check the website often. I also paid $115 however I purchased boots so my total was $136 now the Makies are going for $75 but as you chk out it comes to $78 but does not indicate why. I agree they are an amazing BJD for the price with awesome poseability. The one I created resembles my granddaughter now I want to create one to resemble a fairy. Thank you for an impeccable review, you too are amazing and so informative.

    ReplyDelete
  44. Awesome review!! The idea is great, and the articulations are really well done. BUT These are the UGLIEST dolls I have ever seen, they should get a real sculptor or designer to make the basic faces. They really are poorly planned. The problem is not the style, the problem is that the faces and body sculpture look amateur. You can see it in details like the fingers length, torso collar bones, neck...like they don't have a sense of anatomy, even for exaggerated or fantasy dolls.

    ReplyDelete

I value and welcome all opinions, but comments with abusive or offensive language will be deleted.